Pseudoscience Debate
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 7:37 pm
A debate between Max More and me was just posted:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uDD4JZG7z5M
I'm not going to repeat any of the arguments because I've already covered them all here long ago:
https://www.sparksbrain.org/cryonicsVsAldehyde.html
I'm just going to make a few observations about the actual debate. I honestly got tired of repeating myself when my points were completely lost on Max. I guess that's pretty typical in debates, though. If the other person understood my arguments, I suppose they would already agree with me. It was still surprising to me that he truly did not comprehend the very fundamental fact that cryonics works with cells that have completely died after the first few hours. The point was just totally lost on him. The other interesting moment was when he accused me of being inflammatory. For example, I stated that Dr. Greg Fahy was biased and should be ignored by lay people on the topic of brain preservation. That was not some flippant comment designed to irritate Max. I truly deeply believe that, and I wrote about it quite a bit here with what I feel are very solid arguments for why:
https://www.sparksbrain.org/scientificBasis.html in the section on "Ignoring Certain Scientists".
His surprise when I said that clearly indicates that it was new information to him and that he had not bothered to take the time to read what I had previously written. He was unprepared. I would have been quite happy to explain to him why Fahy should be ignored by lay people. It has absolutely nothing to do with me trying to be inflammatory. I think it's really important for lay people to understand which scientists to listen to and which ones to ignore. There are very clear criteria. It can be a matter of life and death. The explanation I gave is shared by the vast majority of mainstream scientists.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uDD4JZG7z5M
I'm not going to repeat any of the arguments because I've already covered them all here long ago:
https://www.sparksbrain.org/cryonicsVsAldehyde.html
I'm just going to make a few observations about the actual debate. I honestly got tired of repeating myself when my points were completely lost on Max. I guess that's pretty typical in debates, though. If the other person understood my arguments, I suppose they would already agree with me. It was still surprising to me that he truly did not comprehend the very fundamental fact that cryonics works with cells that have completely died after the first few hours. The point was just totally lost on him. The other interesting moment was when he accused me of being inflammatory. For example, I stated that Dr. Greg Fahy was biased and should be ignored by lay people on the topic of brain preservation. That was not some flippant comment designed to irritate Max. I truly deeply believe that, and I wrote about it quite a bit here with what I feel are very solid arguments for why:
https://www.sparksbrain.org/scientificBasis.html in the section on "Ignoring Certain Scientists".
His surprise when I said that clearly indicates that it was new information to him and that he had not bothered to take the time to read what I had previously written. He was unprepared. I would have been quite happy to explain to him why Fahy should be ignored by lay people. It has absolutely nothing to do with me trying to be inflammatory. I think it's really important for lay people to understand which scientists to listen to and which ones to ignore. There are very clear criteria. It can be a matter of life and death. The explanation I gave is shared by the vast majority of mainstream scientists.