Page 1 of 1

Kai, Max, and Aubrey

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 3:53 pm
by jordansparks
Kai Micah Mills, Max More, and Aubrey de Grey had a discussion.
https://biostasis.substack.com/p/immort ... thspan-and
I think what I'll do here is react to a few comments from each of them:
Max: He's pretty irritated at me, coming off the pseudoscience debate that he lost :-). At 50:24, he correctly reminded everyone that I feel cryonics is irrational and that aldehyde fixation is the only hope. But then he went off the rails when he claimed that I claimed that uploading is perfect and there are no problems if you upload. This was followed by a comment at 1:04:11 that I am blithe about brain how uploading would work and I don't give enough technical detail. Of course none of this will be perfect, and it will be extremely complicated. Yes, I'm cheerful and optimistic about it, but I most certainly am not heedless. I'm spending my entire life trying to make improvements to a terrible unavoidable process. The reason I don't go into more detail is because uploading is future technology and we simply can't know the details. We need to focus far more on preservation than revival because it's the only thing we have control over. The other thing that was interesting about Max was that he's not really fundamentally opposed to uploading (1:03:40). This includes openness to multiple duplicates still being "self" (1:07:13). That's great. The other two were just so wrong in this area.
Kai: He thinks reversible suspended animation of the human brain could be perfected within his lifetime (52:29). He's completely wrong about that. He follows a long line of people who were spectacularly overly optimistic about that timeline. Ever since the 60's, we've had a small group of people who felt suspended animation was imminent. Frequently quoted timelines have usually been in the range of 5 to 10 years. That's been going on for 50 years, and it's one of the basic problems with cryonics. Reversible cryonics is not imminent and continuing to go through those motions is pseudoscience. Even if he's right about the timeline, we should not currently be doing cryopreservation on dead cells, and we should use aldehyde fixation prior to demonstration of reversible cryopreservation of an entire human brain. We can have honest disagreement about when suspended animation might be viable, but we absolutely should not be applying inferior technology that intentionally causes damage just because we are hopeful that it might eventually not cause damage. And yes, Kai, the mind is "just" a physical computational device, even though you feel (at 47:38) that's a "loss of respect for the human condition", whatever that word salad means.
Aubrey: He talked a lot about life extension, which is clearly his focus in life. That's fine. Good luck, but biology is far too hard, so he will almost certainly fail. Once the conversation moved to mind backups, copies, and duplicates, he kept talking about intuition. Various thought experiments kept colliding with his intuition (1:00:54). At least he did correctly identify that his intuition was actually not the best approach to be thinking about these issues. If he had completely ignored his intuition and used logic, he would have made some progress toward arriving at the correct conclusion that mental continuity is all that is needed, and that physical continuity is completely irrelevant. I cover this in more detail here:
https://www.sparksbrain.org/uploading.html