A debate between Max More and me was just posted:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uDD4JZG7z5M
I'm not going to repeat any of the arguments because I've already covered them all here long ago:
https://www.sparksbrain.org/cryonicsVsAldehyde.html
I'm just going to make a few observations about the actual debate. I honestly got tired of repeating myself when my points were completely lost on Max. I guess that's pretty typical in debates, though. If the other person understood my arguments, I suppose they would already agree with me. It was still surprising to me that he truly did not comprehend the very fundamental fact that cryonics works with cells that have completely died after the first few hours. The point was just totally lost on him even though the implications are very consequential. The other interesting moments were when he accused me of being inflammatory. For example, I stated that Dr. Greg Fahy was biased and should be ignored by lay people on the topic of brain preservation. That was not some flippant comment designed to irritate Max. I truly deeply believe that, and I wrote about it quite a bit here with what I feel are very solid arguments for why:
https://www.sparksbrain.org/scientificBasis.html in the section on "Ignoring Certain Scientists".
His surprise when I said that clearly indicated that it was new information to him and that he had not bothered to take the time to read what I had previously written. He was unprepared. I would have been quite happy to explain to him why Dr. Fahy must be ignored by lay people in spite of the fact that he is an outstanding scientist. It has absolutely nothing to do with me trying to be inflammatory. I think it's really important for lay people to understand which scientists to listen to and which ones to ignore. There are very clear criteria. It can be a matter of life and death. My justification is shared by the vast majority of mainstream scientists.
Pseudoscience Debate
-
MaximilianKohler
- Posts: 25
- Joined: Sat Mar 09, 2019 4:54 pm
Re: Pseudoscience Debate
He comprehended it just fine. He disagreed that they were "completely dead". So it appears that you're unable to understand your opponent's stances and recognize that you have disagreements.It was still surprising to me that he truly did not comprehend the very fundamental fact that cryonics works with cells that have completely died after the first few hours.
This is not true.The point was just totally lost on him.
Prior to the debate, did you send him links to your writings on the subject? If not, you can't expect him to find everything on his own. Unless he was being paid a lot of money for the debate, there's probably not a big incentive for him to spend a lot of time searching and reading everything you've written.His surprise when I said that clearly indicated that it was new information to him and that he had not bothered to take the time to read what I had previously written.
-
jordansparks
- Site Admin
- Posts: 370
- Joined: Thu Aug 27, 2015 3:59 pm
Re: Pseudoscience Debate
(there are now three different Maxes)
How fascinating that my point was also totally lost on you. I was presenting a scientific fact, not some sort of opinion. There really isn't any nuance here. Those cells are completely dead under the very mainstream scientific definition. That point is actually not up for debate. One could debate that some sort of structure or information is still present, but that's irrelevant because I wasn't claiming that the information suddenly disappeared upon cell death. The consequences of a dead cell are that the metabolic machinery is no longer functional, and so the structure will degrade faster in a dead cell than in a living cell.
Fact: the cells are dead
Fact: dead cells degrade faster
Fact: dead cells can still have structure
Fact: the information that constitutes the mind does not depend on the cells being alive
Btw, the confusion here is not shared by those few remaining scientists who are still sympathetic to cryonics. They already understand that the cells are non-viable within the first few hours of starting a procedure, and they would not disagree with my explanation. The only confusion about the dead cells is among lay people.
How fascinating that my point was also totally lost on you. I was presenting a scientific fact, not some sort of opinion. There really isn't any nuance here. Those cells are completely dead under the very mainstream scientific definition. That point is actually not up for debate. One could debate that some sort of structure or information is still present, but that's irrelevant because I wasn't claiming that the information suddenly disappeared upon cell death. The consequences of a dead cell are that the metabolic machinery is no longer functional, and so the structure will degrade faster in a dead cell than in a living cell.
Fact: the cells are dead
Fact: dead cells degrade faster
Fact: dead cells can still have structure
Fact: the information that constitutes the mind does not depend on the cells being alive
Btw, the confusion here is not shared by those few remaining scientists who are still sympathetic to cryonics. They already understand that the cells are non-viable within the first few hours of starting a procedure, and they would not disagree with my explanation. The only confusion about the dead cells is among lay people.
Agreed. But he also personally attacked me when I said it. Ad hominems are a sign of weak debate skills. It would have been so simple for him to debate that point instead of attacking me and claiming I had bad intentions.there's probably not a big incentive for him to spend a lot of time searching and reading everything you've written
Re: Pseudoscience Debate
Disclaimer - I watched it only for 12 minutes.
In the first section Jordan goes on for about 8 minutes, and then Max goes on for about 6 minutes.
That is LONG in my opinion. Unlikely anything useful can come of such an exchange. Perhaps the 'debate' was intended to be that way - perhaps it drives viewership. Perhaps it may be that _any_ content on this subject regardless of quality out there will be useful for the 'cause'.
My ideal way of discussing a _nuanced_ (so not applicable to common general stuff) topic:
Each person should say 1 or 2 sentences and pause for responses/reactions and most importantly questions from the other person, because even common words ( like 'fact', 'evidence', 'anecdote') that people take for granted can be be interpreted quite differently by the listener. If during this frequent back and forth with small pieces of information one hit a roadblock, then that roadblock has to be addressed before moving on to the next sentence, which means a _temporary_ digression. The discussion HAS to stall if the roadblock cannot be addressed, because if it is not addressed then very soon there will be several layers of doubts/misunderstandings/misgivings etc. which would be extremely difficult in untangle.
Granted that it may even take several days and an extraordinary commitment by BOTH parties, to do a fair exchange of thoughts. If one party does not sense that commitment from the other party then it's not worth talking further.
p.s: I did fast forward and listened to the section where they talk about feedback/endpoint (17 minute mark) . I had a similar conversation with Jordan a few weeks back. Jordan is satisfied with a what I call a short 'feedback' loop, and in my opinion {Jordan-I deleted this short section because it veered into clearly unscientific "arguments"}. But regardless of the terminology, the line of reasoning in this sub-topic that he uses vs most people in cryonics should be clear.
In the first section Jordan goes on for about 8 minutes, and then Max goes on for about 6 minutes.
That is LONG in my opinion. Unlikely anything useful can come of such an exchange. Perhaps the 'debate' was intended to be that way - perhaps it drives viewership. Perhaps it may be that _any_ content on this subject regardless of quality out there will be useful for the 'cause'.
My ideal way of discussing a _nuanced_ (so not applicable to common general stuff) topic:
Each person should say 1 or 2 sentences and pause for responses/reactions and most importantly questions from the other person, because even common words ( like 'fact', 'evidence', 'anecdote') that people take for granted can be be interpreted quite differently by the listener. If during this frequent back and forth with small pieces of information one hit a roadblock, then that roadblock has to be addressed before moving on to the next sentence, which means a _temporary_ digression. The discussion HAS to stall if the roadblock cannot be addressed, because if it is not addressed then very soon there will be several layers of doubts/misunderstandings/misgivings etc. which would be extremely difficult in untangle.
Granted that it may even take several days and an extraordinary commitment by BOTH parties, to do a fair exchange of thoughts. If one party does not sense that commitment from the other party then it's not worth talking further.
p.s: I did fast forward and listened to the section where they talk about feedback/endpoint (17 minute mark) . I had a similar conversation with Jordan a few weeks back. Jordan is satisfied with a what I call a short 'feedback' loop, and in my opinion {Jordan-I deleted this short section because it veered into clearly unscientific "arguments"}. But regardless of the terminology, the line of reasoning in this sub-topic that he uses vs most people in cryonics should be clear.
-
jordansparks
- Site Admin
- Posts: 370
- Joined: Thu Aug 27, 2015 3:59 pm
Re: Pseudoscience Debate
My opening was under 5 minutes. I'll admit I talked too slowly at first. Sorry, Dennis, I had to delete a very short section of your post for being just too far outside the bounds. Facts, evidence, and scientific feedback are well defined.